Sugarland Deny Responsibility for Stage Collapse Tragedy—but Are They Blaming Fans? - E! Online E! Online E! Online Videos Shop Mobile Podcasts RSS Feeds Boards NewsLatest StoriesAsk the Answer B!tchConspiracy CornerCounterpunchMarc MalkinParty GirlSo True So FalseHollywood Goes GreenKim KardashianThe RoyalsTickets and ShowtimesPhotosThe Big PictureFashion PoliceMoviesParty PicsTop Steals of the WeekSo True So False Guessing GameAll Photos »VideoFashion PoliceRed CarpetAcademy AwardsGolden GlobesGrammy AwardsSAG AwardsBAFTA AwardsEmmy AwardsSundance Film FestCannes Film FestPremieres & MorePlay the Pose-OffRock the Red CarpetShop Red CarpetGet the Free AppMoviesAwful TruthWatch w/ KristinThe SoupChelsea LatelyE! ShowsSchedulePersonalitiesPlay A PartE! TunesMessage BoardsRed CarpetSweepstakesAfter LatelyChelsea LatelyDirty SoapDr. 90210E! InvestigatesE! NewsFashion PoliceThe Girls Next DoorHolly's WorldIce Loves CocoKeeping Up with the Kardashians Kendra Khloé and LamarKourtney & Kim Take New YorkMovies We LoveScoutedSex and the CityThe SoupTrue Hollywood StoryMore »
Big Picture
Kate Middleton's School StylePlus, Ashton keeps things colorful and Angelina shines in Zagreb. Get the latest pics!
MORE PHOTOS + Hello, you either have JavaScript turned off or an old version of Adobe's Flash Player. Get the latest Flash player. Most CommentedRobert Pattinson Says He’s "Too Old" for Another Twilight Installment at the Bel Ami Premiere (1114)Morning Mail! Special Blind Vice Edition, in Honor of Vicey Presidents Past: Will Whitney Houston’s Vices Ever Be Revealed? (627)Robert Pattinson and Kristen Stewart Photos Galore! New Pics From Their Post-Twilight Flicks! (519)TV's Top Couple Tournament: And the Winner Is... (514)Weekend Mail! Will a Hunger Games Vice Be Revealed? (421)Morning Mail! Are Former Exes Dianna Agron and Sebastian Stan Feeling the February Love?! (389)Twitter Name Change: Introducing @Ted_Casablanca (325)Morning Mail! Is Leonardo DiCaprio Already Looking for a New Model GF? (207)New Ask Ted Video! Should Kristen Stewart Play Elizabeth Taylor? (178)Glee-Dux: Guess Who's Back?! V-Day Episode Delivers Romance, Smooches and Shockers! (178)Top 10 StoriesSugarland Deny Responsibility for Stage Collapse Tragedy—but Are They Blaming Fans? Paris Hilton Wins $30,000 While Celebrating Birthday in Las VegasSpoiler Chat Daily: Danger Ahead for a Glee Couple? Plus, Scoop on Justified, Smash and MoreChris Brown and Rihanna Together Again? Pair Unveil Two New Musical Collaborations on TwitterChris Brown Sends Rihanna Birthday Wishes on TwitterBethenny Frankel Reveals That She Had a Miscarriage It's Official: Lindsay Lohan Confirmed to Host SNL All Hail: Will Ferrell Dons Crown in Mardi Gras ParadeGhost Rider Franchise Flames Out as Channing Tatum, Denzel Washington Stay Hot Best Picture Upset Brewing at the Oscars?! Uh, NoFashion Police
Kirsten's Major Glam Plus, Malin Akerman and Christina Ricci. Rate the highs and lows!
MORE PHOTOS +Top Galleries
Stars Meet the President
Stars Playing President
Divas Who Died Too Soon
2012 Image Awards: Arrivals
MORE PHOTOS +-->
#brick-swisssh a:hover {background-color:transparent;}
Our Partners
Hello, you either have JavaScript turned off or an old version of Adobe's Flash Player. Get the latest Flash player. Sugarland Deny Responsibility for Stage Collapse Tragedy—but Are They Blaming Fans? Today 8:55 AM PSTby Gina Serpe
Mike Coppola/Getty Images, Joey Foley/Getty Images
Sugarland have reluctantly waded into the blame game. Though mostly to make sure that the fingers aren't pointed anywhere near their direction.
The country duo has responded to a negligence suit filed against them claiming that the band was at least partly responsible for the tragic and deadly Indiana State Fair stage collapse last year.
Needless to say, Jennifer Nettles and Kristian Bush beg to differ.
MORE: Sugarland sued for state fair stage collapse
Instead of accepting blame for the Aug. 13 tragedy, in which seven people were killed and 40 injured when severe weather conditions toppled the front of the stage, Sugarland claims in documents obtained by Indy's WRTV, that the devastation was the result of a "gust of wind of unprecedented intensity" and "a true accident, or act of God."
Hello, you either have JavaScript turned off or an old version of Adobe's Flash Player. Get the latest Flash player.
And, it follows, nothing they either contributed to or could have prevented.
Filed last November, the civil suit accused the band, the concert's promoters and several other companies responsible for building the stage of negligence, claiming they allowed it to become overloaded, failed to properly monitor the encroaching and threatening weather and finally failed to properly evacuate the area in a timely manner.
In their response to the filing, Sugarland argues that "they had nothing to with the construction of the venue" or therefore its safety.
MORE: Indiana settles up for state fair stage collapse
"The incident at issue in this litigation resulted from a gust of wind of unprecedented intensity, which caused a structure that may have been improperly designed, maintained and/or inspected to fail," the documents read. "As such, this was a true accident or Act of God."
Oddly, they also seemed to blame some of the victims themselves for their injuries, stating that "some or all of the plaintiffs failed to exercise due care for their own safety" and further that "some or all of the plaintiffs knowingly and voluntarily assumed and/or incurred the risk of injury to themselves."
Blaming the victims? Not the best way to endear yourselves to fans, Sugarland.
MORE: Woman accused of faking injuries from Sugarland tragedy
Meanwhile, the band also took time to direct the litigious gaze of the plaintiffs elsewhere, saying that Indiana State Fair officials, state police and members of the labor union who helped construct the stage that ultimately collapsed were really the ones responsible for the horrific incident, and that they—under their company's name of Lucky Star Inc.—had no control or say in the construction of the stage.
"Lucky Star Inc. did not have any control over the size of the stage nor the public address system, as this was all provided for by the Indiana Fair Board."
The lawsuit, filed on behalf of 51 people total, including the families and estates of four deceased fans as well as some of the injured audience, is seeking unspecified damages.
PHOTOS: 2012 Grammys: Winners
Tweet5 Commentsfiled undercourthouse,top stories,Music,concerts,lawsuit,deathEditor's Picks
Latest DetailsLatest DetailsWhitney Funeral
Hot Photos
Together Again?Together Again?Latest on Rihanna5 CommentsShow the next 1 - 0 of 5 commentsNow loading...Add Your Comment!Guests
E! Online members
Register | Forgot password?
Play nice and have fun. And please, no HTML tags or special characters including [&*#()!@$].
You've got 1000 characters left.Post Comment E! OnlineSend Us Your Feedback » NewsLatest StoriesMarc MalkinParty GirlAnswer BitchMovie ReviewsPhotosThe Big PictureFashion PoliceParty PicsMoviesVideoFashion PoliceRed CarpetAcademy AwardsGolden GlobesGrammy AwardsSAG AwardsBAFTA AwardsEmmy AwardsSundance Film Fest Cannes Film FestPremieres & MoreE! ShowsSchedulePersonalitiesPlay a PartE! TunesMessage boardsWATCH with KRISTINAWFUL TRUTHSHOP E!MORESweepstakesNewslettersMobilePodcastsRSS FeedsIndependent Programming ReportAbout UsContact UsStaffCareersFAQ
![]()
AdChoicesAdvertiseSitemap Use of this site signifies your acceptance of the Privacy Policy and Terms of Use.
Copyright 2012 E! Entertainment Television, LLC. A Division of NBCUniversal.E! International Edition:
USA
AustraliaGermanyItalyFranceUKCanadaUSA @import url('http://s3.amazonaws.com/getsatisfaction.com/feedback/feedback.css');
View the
Original article
Getty Images 
Tweet25 Commentsfiled undertaylor swift,exclusives,top stories,Music,whitney houston,MoviesEditor's Picks
Hot Photos
Statue Faves?Statue Faves?Oscars Cheat Sheet25 CommentsShow the next 1 - 0 of 25 commentsNow loading...Add Your Comment!GuestsE! Online members
Jeff Kravitz/FilmMagic 
Tweet16 Commentsfiled undersaturday night live,top stories,weekend wrap-up,whitney houston,box office,deathEditor's Picks